The Record

The Hooman Asbaghi Case

A filing is not a verdict. Nothing on this site is a finding of liability.

Section 09

Connections

Documented overlaps of people, institutions, and dates. Overlap is not guilt. A possible setting is not a named shipment.

What overlap does and does not show

A claim of an unauthorized smart hip would be easier to dismiss if the year, hospital, surgeon, or research neighborhood did not exist. They do. Scripps hosted SCORE. Walker operated. Public copy describes electronic knees and, later, smart shoulders. His 2025 chart still describes the hips he received as standard Stryker without electronics. Both can be shown. Neither is hidden.

documented

Padtan Elm → Farideh Kavesh

1999 power of attorney + share lists

She is printed as his attorney as early as July 2003 minutes, and later as an officer. After 1999 that is the default reading. Paper is not a theft finding. An attorney-in-fact has a duty to act in the principal’s interest; whether that duty was kept is the civil question.

documented

Hooman Asbaghi → Scripps Green / Walker

2015 and 2017 THA faces

Surgeries happened. Device identity on staff lists is conventional Stryker.

documented

Walker → Colwell / D’Lima / SCORE

co-author lines on hip papers 1994–2014; same campus; Colwell founded the division in 1977 and the lower-extremity fellowship in 1984 as director; Walker joined 1983; SCMG president by 25 Jan 2017 while Colwell and D’Lima remained on SCORE copy; Walker’s bio prints faculty guiding fellows 30+ years; current SCMG page lists Bugbee as program director

Bibliography. Same campus during Walker’s dated SCMG presidency (25 Jan 2017 onward) is overlap, not an org chart that Colwell or D’Lima reported to him. SCORE’s electronic knee is public campus copy — four named testers by 2011, coil-activated in 2004. Fall 2004 magazine prints the fellowship under the joint direction of Walker and Colwell; quote as printed, do not invert. Not an operative link that these two stems were that program.

documented

Walker → Scripps Clinic Medical Group presidency

Scripps news 25 Jan 2017; Patch 27 Aug 2018; Scripps news 9 Nov 2020 president and CEO of SCMG; NPI 16 May 2023 PRESIDENT

SCMG is the physician group, not Scripps Health. Dated as president before the 23 Oct 2017 left THA. The 9 Oct 2015 right THA is not locked as president on these faces. A medical-group presidency is not a finding he ran an unauthorized implant program.

conflict

Sees existing patients only → Out of office until 1/29/2027 / retired / no response

public physician-page cover vs portal banners on the hospital file

Cover prints Sees existing patients only. Portal: OOO until 1/29/2027; 24 Feb staff Walker has retired; 21 Apr to Hong: retired, took questions, no response, question removed. He writes Walker refused him since 2023 — that since-2023 sentence is his; no 2023 refusal letter is on this file.

documented

Kenneth J. Schmidt → Clifford W. Colwell Jr.

2019 Orthopedics metal-allergy TKA paper; Schmidt named assistant on the 2015 packet

The 2015 assistant later publishes with Colwell. Not a smart-implant paper. A 2025 Journal of Arthroplasty metal-hypersensitivity title is a different author team.

circumstantial

Colwell → Stryker Trident ceramic system

manufacturer acknowledgements list him as a principal investigator, Scripps Clinic La Jolla

Staff lists name a Trident PSL HA cup. An investigator list is not a finding electronics were in the shell, and is not a finding that protocol was used on 9 Oct 2015. The 2014 ceramic-liner paper with Walker and Colwell used Trident PSL / Super Secur-Fit Plus / Biolox in a 169-patient series; Colwell disclosed Stryker research support outside the work; Walker declared none. Same product family, not a finding his cups were among the 169.

context

Stryker Corporation public record → Staff lists naming Trident / Secur-Fit / Biolox

same manufacturer, different product families

Rejuvenate / ABG II modular-neck settlements (2014 ~$1.43B; 2017 ~$2.0–$2.2B), OtisMed knee guides ($80M, 8 Dec 2014), OP-1 Biotech plea (one misdemeanor, $15M, 18 Jan 2012), and two SEC FCPA books-and-records orders ($13.28M in 2013; $7.8M in 2018) are the company’s public enforcement paper. They are not a finding that electronics sat in these two stems.

context

The Scripps Research Institute $10M NIH settlement (11 Sep 2020) → Scripps Health $1.5M PT settlement (19 Jan 2018) and 2021 ransomware class settlement

shared city name, three different entities

Research Institute ≠ Health hospital system ≠ Scripps Green, where the two THAs were charted. Grant-accounting, physical-therapy billing, and a data-breach payout are not implant telemetry.

documented

Walker → San Diego Padres

Scripps bio: team physician over 15 years, including 1984 and 1998 pennants

Colwell’s letterhead bio prints Padres team physician for the past 15 years; San Diego Foundation copy later prints about 25. Keep both. The 14 Feb 2007 contract names Fronek as head team physician and Larry Harrison as CEO of Scripps Clinic — Walker and Colwell are not on that staff list. Overlap of two team physicians is on the bios. A later family-fundraising overlap is not this edge.

context

SCORE e-knee (2004–2011) → Persona IQ (2021) / CBS base-station knee (2022)

same question — instrumented joints — different devices

SCORE’s e-knee is a consented research knee with a removable activation coil and a nearby computer. Persona IQ is a Zimmer Biomet / Canary commercial tibial extension cleared 30 August 2021; CBS 2 December 2022 prints a nightstand base station, no GPS, 10-year battery. Neither is a 2015 Stryker hip. Do not fuse them.

circumstantial

Ommid Asbaghi → Curebound / Scripps Research / Moores

Bill’s Angels captions + beneficiary lists

Family name on a fundraiser that supports institutions in the same city. A 2025 captains letter now prints her name and Scripps Research on one page. Not enrollment.

circumstantial

Padtan Elm ELISA catalog (thyroid, PSA, ferritin…) → MyScripps biomarker names

archived padtan.com product names vs portal test names

Name overlap is real if both lists are shown. It is not a wire from a hip to Tehran.

conflict

Sheean lab labels 2016 → Karches “I do not know a Dr. Sheean”

same patient portal, different faces

Both sentences stay. Neither is deleted to make a cleaner story.

conflict

Test Details 677C>T → Result Trends c.675C>T

same collection 13 Oct 2016 14:20

Both strings are on portal faces. Do not call 675 a typo. Do not call 677 a glitch. Do not treat the mismatch as finished proof of fabrication.

alleged

Codex DNA monument → MTHFR 13 Oct 2016

Folder 6 filename + Article 2

Street View shows co-signed Scripps/Codex monument. The MTHFR crop does not print Codex. Keep them separate until a face names the lab.

circumstantial

Central Lab 9535 Waples St. 150 → Codex DNA Suite 100

same street number; catecholamines face vs 2021 Codex SEC filing vs Scripps CLIA

Scripps Medical Laboratory – Sorrento Mesa is publicly listed at 9535 Waples St Ste 150. Codex DNA listed Suite 100 in the same building. The catecholamines face matches the Scripps suite, not Codex. Sharing a building is not the same as running the assay.

conflict

Walker / Greene / Risk Management 2025 denials → Thin notes, 675/677, Sheean vs Karches, SCORE copy

same case file, different faces

Official negatives stay on the table. They do not take the other faces off the table. The site does not write guilty. It also does not write closed.

circumstantial

14 January 2013 alleged meeting → Gerloni v. Zanetti affirmed 1 February 2013

eighteen calendar days

Two public dates. The unpublished opinion (D059695) is now mounted as caption, short holding, and deposition as the court recited it: derivative, no standing; contract and fraud failed on deposition. The same opinion recites CBI’s purchase of Transgenix and Gerloni as CBI CEO in 2005. Coordination as a patent shield is his claim. A cancer-vaccine dispute at UCSD is not a Tehran share deed.

context

Nature, 13 Feb 1997 → Maurizio Zanetti / UCSD

published news item on a misconduct charge

Nature reported allegations that included human-experiment and biosafety policy, dual UCSD panels, and a DOJ-intervened whistleblower suit. Zanetti denied misconduct. The later Gerloni opinion recites a tenure-committee exoneration. Keep both. This is not a verdict of unconsented trials, and it is not Padtan Elm.

documented

Mara Gerloni → Cosmo Bioscience, Inc. / Cosmo Pharmaceuticals NV

2013 opinion recitation + ResearchGate snippet + image result

The unpublished opinion recites that in 2005 she left UCSD to become CBI’s CEO. ResearchGate still prints CEO at Cosmo Bioscience. An image result captions Cosmo Pharmaceuticals NV. Two public names. Not proof they are one legal entity, and not a finding about Iranian trials.

documented

Cosmo Bioscience → Adamis Pharmaceuticals / Zanetti

Cosmo 10-K Note 8 as printed

May 2010 San Diego caption. License from Eurogen BV. Stayed November 2010. A securities note is not a Tehran share deed.

documented

Behlouli–Narges call → Farideh Kavesh

Narges names her as the person who can explain

On the call she says she did not take action and that Ms. Kavesh can give the best explanations. That is what she said. It is not the missing 2013 deed, and it is not a finding that a Columbia firm served process.

documented

Ommid Asbaghi / Farideh Kavesh → Trans In’Tech, LLC

California entity records

The company exists. The public chart names Farideh and Ommid on the same face — that chart is on both of their pages. Public officer lines include family names. That it was a cover for Zanetti patents or Iranian trials is the allegation, not the filing.

circumstantial

Carolin Botzenhardt → Deutsche Bank 2015 Iran-sanctions penalty

same employer, overlapping years

The bank’s penalty is public. It does not name her. NYDFS describes dollar-clearing, not a private-wealth book. A job overlap is not a wire to Padtan Elm.

documented

Ommid Asbaghi → Carolin Botzenhardt

Concert for Cures host committee

One printed list names Ommid Asbaghi & Levant Alkibay and Carolin Botzenhardt & Paul Noury. A 2022 gallery filename names both women in one photograph. That is continued public proximity after the claimed early-2000s divorce. It is not a finding they moved money.

documented

Scripps visit note → Labs / DEXA from Iran

Folder 6 Fabricated Docs still — Grok Sessions 171–172, mounted here

The chart names Iran. It sources the Iran testosterone as “patient states.” Vitamin D 11/2016 and a 24-hour urine are also named as Iran. No performing laboratory is printed. That is not a lab-to-lab dump from Pathobiology Laboratory Center, and it is not nothing. His sentence is that he never consented to share mother’s-lab work and never discussed Iran with these doctors. Sit those next to patient-states. The laboratory’s own magnitude is on /pathobiology.

documented

Hooman Asbaghi → Massoud Ghasemi

27 Aug 2002 board page (Madayen / Bionic) + 2024 official notice

They are printed together on a 2002 approval page. In 2024 Ghasemi is noticed, with Narges Javad, about questions concerning Hooman — that notice belongs later in the story. A board page is not a 1991 stent log. A notice is not a judgment.

documented

Ghasemi CV → Valeix / Teirstein / Saeed / Imam Khomeini / Scripps 2003

named references and certificates on his own profile

Valeix, Saeed, and Teirstein are printed as references. France 1993 and Scripps 2003 are printed as certificates. Imam Khomeini is printed as a current post. Richard Schatz is not on that list. References are not a training log for Palmaz-Schatz in 1991–93. The 2003 Scripps line is an independent match to the claim he was in San Diego around 2000/2003. It is not proof Hooman made the introduction.

circumstantial

Claim: he brought Ghasemi to San Diego ~2000/2003 → Ghasemi’s own CV — Scripps Clinic certificate 2003

same year, same campus, printed independently on Ghasemi’s paper

Credibility of the San Diego claim, not a finding that Hooman arranged it. Folder 3 has no boarding pass, Scripps badge, or arranging letter. The CV already independently matches year and campus. Introduction stays the claim. The CV also lists M. Saeed and Paul Teirstein as Scripps references — the same names the narrative uses. Those lines are references. Mohsin Saeed is pinned for later.

circumstantial

Palmaz-Schatz calendar → Claimed Iran introductions 1991–93

first coronary implant Dec 1987; U.S. iliac 1991; U.S. coronary PMA Aug 1994; international coronary use already underway by 1991

U.S. coronary approval in 1994 does not close the early-1990s window. Palmaz records coronary work in Europe, Japan, and Latin America before that PMA. Tehran sources date angioplasty expansion to 1370 SH (1991–92). Foreign proctors were ordinary. Valeix’s 1992–93 papers are Wiktor, a different stent. The setting makes the activity possible. No warehouse page puts Hooman’s name on a Palmaz-Schatz shipment.

documented

Kianoosh Behlouli → Padtan Elm inspector seat, 2011–2013

Warehouse minutes 1390/5/18 + matching gazettes + Rasmio dump

Gazettes name him alternate inspector; Amargaran Accounting is principal. The later Farsi letter’s heading says principal. Keep both. The match of man and years is witness credibility. It is not a court finding of theft.

circumstantial

Official gazette 24 Dey 1391 → Alleged 14 January 2013 share transfer

Same calendar day; published act is an objects amendment adding export of all permitted goods

A meeting is on the register that day. The published act is not a share deed. The deed has not been mounted. Absence of that deed is expected if concealment is the theory; absence is not itself the proof.

circumstantial

14 Jan 2013 export-clause gazette → 1 Jul 2013 EO 13645 / IFCA effective

same six-month window; padtanteb.ir first Wayback save 23 June 2013 sits between them

The dates are real. IFCA is sectoral (energy, shipping, shipbuilding, rial, auto), not a finding that IVD exports were newly banned that morning. Broader Iran sanctions already existed. An old registered company with a long gazette trail is a harder KYC vehicle than a clean new name — that is the open question. It is not a closing that they created a shell to evade. Rasmio now prints شرکت پادتن طب, national ID 10101097879, register 1445, founded 1366/02/07. Marketing copy still claims 1369/1990. A new website is not a new legal entity.

conflict

Padtan Teb self-description → padtanteb.ir first archive 23 Jun 2013

own copy claims 1987 or 1990; first listed Wayback save is June 2013

Live padtanteb.ir says 1366. Warehouse introduction still says 1369 / 1990. Rasmio prints founded 1366/02/07 for national ID 10101097879, register 1445. Archive calendar for padtanteb.ir starts 23 June 2013. Four Google stills in the parent folder show related-name logos (Elm, Padza, Danesh, Pishtaz Teb). Those stills are not this register page. Padza Padtan dates itself to 2017 — a later related-name company, not the 2013 vehicle. سحر اندیش (2016) and تجهیز (2014) are later name-family companies, not the 1366 LLC.

documented

Narges Javad → Padtan Elm

Oct 2002 equal share; May 2012 managing director; 2024 notice; Behlouli call

She is not on the 1996 founding minutes. She is on later company paper as owner and then as managing director. On a warehouse call identified as Behlouli and Narges she declines to explain a year-92 share movement and names Ms. Kavesh. That is a later-entry record plus what she said on the line, not a 1995 founding.

circumstantial

Padtan Elm ELISA kits → Iranome catalog

same country; kit company documented; Iranome FAQ names Illumina, not Padtan

A working IVD company and a later public genomic catalog can exist in the same industry without one owning the other. Human Mutation 2019: 1,575,702 variants, 308,311 novel, 800 people in eight groups; FAQ names Illumina sequencers and a University of Toronto collaboration. No page currently attributes Iranome to Padtan, Farideh, or Hooman. Capability is not guilt.

circumstantial

Iranome FAQ — Illumina sequencers → Howard Birndorf’s public Illumina 1998 participation

same instrument company; friendship claimed

The catalog used Illumina machines. Birndorf participated in Illumina’s founding. That is San Diego biotech history next to a platform name. It is not a finding he connected Iranome, attended a 1999 wedding with Hooman, or funded a tranche.

alleged

Thermo Fisher Life Technologies close, 3 Feb 2014 → Claimed Padtan Elm OEM

public acquisition calendar vs no contract in the warehouse

Life Tech closed 3 February 2014 (announced April 2013). Applied Biosystems and Invitrogen sit in that family. Bio-Rad does not. Archived padtan.com advertised OEM-style IVD work. A Thermo–Padtan contract is not mounted. Catalog search hitting yeast gene Elm1 is a string collision.

alleged

Leonardo Lauciello, Roche pRED Basel → Alleged PTELM / Roche license, 15 Mar 2016

public person; warehouse dump held

He is a real Roche early-development portfolio manager. Dollar figures and royalty percentages stay holdback. PTELM has no public Zurich register page here. Name resemblance to Padtan Elm is an observation.

documented

Padtan Elm commercial IgE kit → Published sulfur-mustard small-airway methods

methods line: IgE (Padtan Elm co)

Independent paper used a named Padtan Elm kit. That is supplier-in-the-literature, not a 2013 transfer and not a Roche contract.

documented

Labquality EIA code 821 email, 24 Nov 2016 → Padtan Elm kits

Finnish EQA provider grouped results by Padtan reagents; catalog title prints code 821

The original is Päivi Ranta’s email, not a Labquality website. A client more than ten years earlier used Padtan reagents. That is EQA footprint for the kits. It is not a share deed and not a Thermo OEM. The 2014 10-K pages in the same folder do not name Padtan.

documented

Wiley methods §2.2 + colonoscopy/PSA paper → Padtan Elm of Tehran as named supplier

SinaClon on the same chemicals page; “Padtan elm kit (made in Iran)” for PSA; ferritin/Hb companion line

Remainder of the Articles Naming Padtan ELM folder. Second IgE PDF is the same 1.88 MB file, not a second citation. Elsevier “Alnylam AND Padtan Elm” bookstore search is a search hit, not a paper.

documented

2018 ELISA-plate contract → Farideh Kavesh and Soudabeh Keykavousi as authorized board

Padtan Elm Evidence Doc1 — register 127180, 30,000 Biomat plates, catalog MGOIF-HB8

Hard commercial paper after the alleged 2013 exclusion. Euro totals held off the public caption. A plate purchase is not the missing deed and not a finding about his hips.

documented

Farci Rasmio dump (national ID 10101705792) → 2011 objects gazette news 11777168

extraordinary meeting 8/3/90; gazette 1391/03/08; same register 127180 as the English dump

Unique gazette the English extract did not table: kit production, import of production inputs, diagnostic-kit research. Two years before the 14 January 2013 export-clause gazette. Not the missing share deed. Graph links to Central Pathobiology Lab and Amargaran are supporting network, not theft. The public face of Pathobiology Laboratory Center is now its own page.

documented

Pathobiology Laboratory Center → Central Bank, Armed Forces medical services, Iran Air, SSO, major banks

contracted-institutions page on path-lab.ir

Tiles are laboratory insurance: a contracted lab provider for covered members. That is magnitude as they printed it. It is not a finding of illicit finance. Wet-ink ISO 9001 from BSI (UK 2010) through TÜV AUSTRIA (2020) and six 2024 RIQAS programmes sit on /pathobiology. That is QMS and EQA, not ISO 15189 and not illicit finance.

circumstantial

Pathobiology Laboratory Center public menu / QMS rows 436–437 → Hooman 13 Oct 2016 MTHFR (C677T + A1298C compound heterozygous)

same two variant names

Assay-name overlap. His draw is 2016. The C677T listing on path-lab.ir prints created 1400/11/3 (~23 January 2022). Does not prove this lab ran that test, and does not prove Iran drawings in Scripps came from here.

documented

Farideh Kavesh → Pathobiology Laboratory Center

Rasmio / روزنامه رسمی gazette 1402/08/22 of minutes 1402/06/29

نایب رئیس هیئت مدیره و مدیرعامل through 1404/06/29. Same titles on minutes 1400/04/15. سیدمهدی مقیمی is رئیس هیئت مدیره — she is not board chair. The website still does not print her name. A thanks plaque addresses عالم حکیم; keep that as a named-head conflict, not a deletion of the gazette.

documented

Farideh Kavesh → Padtan Elm and Pathobiology Laboratory Center

same person, three companies on one Rasmio table

Her Rasmio profile prints three boards: Padtan Elm vice-chair through 1404/08/17; Pathobiology Laboratory Center board member through 1404/06/29; زیست شیمی board member in 1393–1395. The laboratory gazette, not that table, names her CEO. Karourian chairs Padtan Elm. Behnam Safayi Zadeh is CEO of Padtan Elm from outside the board. زیست شیمی is not fused into the other two. Three rows are not a theft finding. The 25% founder line plus the 1999 exercise of his printed 25% line is paper arithmetic, not a court finding of 50% voting control.

documented

Dr Alireza Karourian / A.R. Korourian / علیرضا کروریان → Pathobiology Laboratory Center and Padtan Elm

building directory + path-lab.ir QC Manager + Padtan gazette chair

Same printed name on three faces: DR. A.R. KOROURIAN M.D. on the laboratory directory; مسئول کنترل کیفیت on the physicians table; رئیس هیئت مدیره of Padtan Elm through 1404/08/17. Transliterations Korourian / Karourian / KOROURIAN stay. He is on the 1397 Padtan attendance list. Name overlap is documented. That she seated him on Padtan because he reports to her at the lab is alleged.

documented

Dr M. Gerowgan / محمد کروگان / دکتر گروگان → Pathobiology Laboratory Center

building directory + PLC gazette board member

Plate prints گروگان / GEROWGAN. Gazette prints محمد کروگان as عضو هیئت مدیره of the laboratory company, with Farideh vice-chair and CEO. He is not on the live physicians table and not on the current Padtan Elm officer table. Keep the spellings. Do not flatten into a national-ID match on the public page.

documented

Pathobiology Laboratory Center → BSI / TÜV NORD / NACI / TÜV AUSTRIA / RIQAS

wet-ink ISO 9001 certificates 2010–2020 and six 2024 RIQAS programmes

International QMS issuers (UK, Germany, Iran, Austria) and a UK/UKAS proficiency scheme across chemistry, coagulation, haematology, HbA1c, immunoassay, and maternal screening. That is capability and scale as printed. ISO 9001 is not ISO 15189. Participation is not a 2016 performing-lab line.

alleged

Hooman’s presentation of related-name IVD marks → Padtan Elm / Padza Pajooh / PadTan Danesh / Pishtaz Teb

four Google-image stills in the shell folder; similar names and badge logos

This is what he presented as shells of the original company. Name and logo similarity is on the stills. It is not a finding they are one legal entity or that anyone created a shell to evade. Pishtaz Teb is a named 2017 defendant. Padza’s public founder paper names Fatemeh Rabbani, 2017.

documented

iranindustry.de PADTAN ELM CO → PADTAN DAROU CO on the next line

IMG_3575 — Narges Javad manager of Elm; Asadizade manager of Darou

Name-family neighbor on a public directory. Narges is printed as manager of Padtan Elm. She is not printed as manager of Padtan Darou on this page.

conflict

1378 power of attorney, office 198 → 1392 power of attorney, office 815

two CamScanner originals; filenames both say 1999

The full uncropped 815 scan is what was sent as the 1999 original. The face is 1392. Keep both instruments. Filename is a label.

conflict

Thermo Fisher catalog “Padtan Elm” → Yeast gene Elm1

TaqMan assay Sc04140348_s1, species Baker’s yeast

The search string hits a gene name. That is not a distribution contract. A warehouse still of an Academia.edu listing titles a paper “thermo Fisher and Padtan Elm” under his name. That listing is not his paper. It was found by the investigator and later disappeared. Keep the anomaly. Do not treat it as his authorship.

documented

Saqvan Ali → Hooman Asbaghi

13 Feb 2020 Gmail · 26 Mar 2024 signed statement · 19 Jun 2026 notarized declaration

An AT&T Del Mar employee wrote to the customer in 2020, signed in 2024, and swore in 2026. That is a witness file. It is not a court finding that AT&T tracked him.

documented

John Goodrich → AT&T Del Mar Highlands

LinkedIn Retail Store Manager, Del Mar, Jun 2017–Jan 2019

Right name, right title, right city, in the window of 24 June 2018. The “not crazy / track him all day” sentence is Saqvan’s, not this still.

documented

Jesus M. Barraza → AT&T San Diego–area retail

LinkedIn Area Retail Sales Manager Jul 2014–Mar 2025, 17 distribution points

Regional match to the district manager Saqvan names. Stills do not print Del Mar Highlands. Not a finding he ordered surveillance.

alleged

Ommid Asbaghi → AT&T Del Mar Highlands

Saqvan’s 2020 email, 2024 statement, and 2026 declaration naming the sister / “Ommid” in the store

Three writings, one witness, one store. iCloud delete request and refusal are his. June 24 2018 vs early 2019 stays. Not a finding she accessed an account. Same person as Who is Ommid Asbaghi — one window.

circumstantial

AT&T Del Mar Highlands (3435 Del Mar Heights Rd, Suite D2) → Hooman’s residence

public store locator vs where he lived

The store is public. Proximity is geography. The home address is held off this site. A map pin is not tracking.

conflict

Saqvan 2024 “assistant manager / March 2018” → Saqvan 2026 “CSR / January 2017–March 2021”

same witness, two employment faces

Keep both. The 2026 sworn packet is the one that dates the window. Neither is a LinkedIn still of Saqvan.

conflict

Brian Brown named in 2024/2026 → Brian Brown, National Director of Sales, AT&T Consulting, New York

folder supplied under that name

The New York consulting director is the wrong seat to publish as identity proof. Not mounted. San Diego Brian/Bryan Brown remains open.

documented

Hooman Asbaghi → Park Laurel Owners Association

caption filed 11 Jun 2018, dismissed without prejudice 27 Jul 2018

He sued the association of the building at 2500 Sixth Ave. Judge Timothy Taylor. Figley is named on the docket as the association’s TRO-opposition declarant. A caption is not a finding of surveillance.

documented

Ryan Figley → Park Laurel

LinkedIn GM Nov 2014–Mar 2022 + HOA letter returning him 12 Feb 2019

Right name, right building, overlapping the 2018 lawsuit. Capital projects as listed are building-wide. LinkedIn does not print a gap; the letter does. Keep both.

documented

Jeremy Rupel → Park Laurel Owners Association

3 Oct 2018 GM letterhead + Feb 2019 resignation letter

Named CMCA General Manager on association paper, then a family-care resignation with a welcome-back. Not a finding he was fired for coming clean.

alleged

Figley LinkedIn capital projects → Claimed in-unit retrofit

building-wide work on a résumé vs his account of devices in an apartment

Elevators, roof air handlers, pool deck, exterior paint are on the face. Fiber and an apartment are not. Overlap is not a finding the unit was fitted.

documented

Hooman’s 7 Apr 2025 tribute comment → Jeremy Rupel

public funeral-home wall under Hooman’s name

The comment is on the wall, signed Hooman Asbaghi, 7 April 2025. That writing exists. What Jeremy said, and whether he was going to testify, are not in this warehouse. Not a homicide finding.

circumstantial

Park Laurel caption, Jun–Jul 2018 → AT&T Del Mar witness file

same summer; AT&T window continues into 2019

Two files, one city, overlapping months. The AT&T statement is one window. This building file is another. Overlap of calendar is not a finding they were one program.

circumstantial

Feb 2019 resignation letter → 20 Aug 2020 death in Springfield

eighteen months and a move to Missouri on the obituary

Proven: he was GM, he resigned, Figley returned, he died. Unproven: what he said, that he was going to testify. A mundane death remains possible. The dates stay. This site does not write the leap.

documented

DuckDuckGo still, HAA- Enterprises, 6 Mar 2025 → github.com/sayem314/hooman

same search result: his listing at 2500 6th Ave immediately above the public one-liner

The still prints both. Repository created 3 May 2020. “Hooman” can also mean humanize; the package is named hoomanize. That coincidence is not hidden. An HAA Enterprises folder on Figley’s computer is recall, not in this warehouse.

circumstantial

sayem314/hooman public description → AT&T witness file — sister receiving account material

public interceptor named hoomanize sitting next to his own listing; alleged sister access in a different window

Two files, one name. Putting the public description next to what Saqvan alleges a sister was receiving is an anomaly. It is not a finding the package was used or that it opened his accounts. Methods stay off this page. The GitHub harvest is one window.

documented

Apple alert, Dear Ommid → farideh.kavesh@icloud.com

2020 App Store download body on the forwarded still

Apple’s template names that Apple ID and greets Ommid. The still is a forward. To: is not on the face.

circumstantial

Dear Ommid / ommid-farideh → Ommid Asbaghi

greeting on the 2020 alert; username in the 1 Dec 2022 letter

Same given name as the sister. He says they do not Family-Share and he does not speak to her. Name overlap plus his household account is the anomaly. Not a finding she downloaded ICQ.

circumstantial

2020 ICQ download alert → 1 Dec 2022 Laincsek letter

same Apple ID farideh.kavesh@icloud.com, two years later, in his Proton as a folder named ommid-farideh

He wrote the 2022 complaint. That writing exists. It does not prove the software ran. Hoghooghi as outer forward is on the face; the 16 February 2025 email and DC Bar form sit on /apple-id#hoghooghi.

documented

Ommid S. Asbaghi, trustee → Asbaghi Revocable Trust outgoing wire, 5 Jan 2017

First Republic notice naming her as TTEE, $950,000 outgoing

Bank paper. Beneficiary is not on the face. Family-loan document, not a tax finding, not a finding it was paid to him.

documented

Hooman Telegram to Sayem → sayem314, author of the public hooman package

Remember me still; Sayem dates a prior contact to early 2023

He wrote to the author. His description of a hacking program is alleged as to the facts. Year of the still is not printed.

circumstantial

sayem314/hooman About tags → AT&T witness file — sister receiving account material

published interceptor/captcha/Cloudflare purpose sitting next to his listing on the HAA still

What the package is published to do, plus what Saqvan wrote a sister had on a phone. Two windows. Anomaly, not a use finding. Methods stay off the public page.

circumstantial

iOS: Unable to Stop Sharing Location → AT&T witness file — sister receiving account material

Screen Time restrictions or a managed device profile, read next to alleged sister access in a different window

Apple’s dialog exists. Who set Screen Time is not on the face. A passcode the owner set prints the same sentence. The AT&T file is context, not a finding she enrolled the phone. Phone-anomaly harvest is one window.

circumstantial

Microsoft: Created by your IT department → AT&T witness file — sister receiving account material

work-or-school picker on an email that also had a personal Microsoft account

The picker exists. The email is not printed. Does not prove the family was that IT department.

documented

ProtonMail Contacts, clock 19:47 → Babak Hoghooghi

name and bhoghooghi@bcr-dc.com printed many times on one Contacts list

The duplication is on the face. A sync artifact can print the same list. Not a finding he cloned the address book. The Bar form is a complaint sent, not this Contacts edge.

circumstantial

Padres Pedal / Curebound funds Moores → Maurizio Zanetti, Laboratory of Immunology at Moores

beneficiary list on captains letter and Pedal copy; Zanetti director page at UCSD Moores

Fundraising geography. Moores’ grants directory opens with Curebound/Pedal and lists Zanetti’s 2021 Gleiberman HNSC pilot as Project 3 on the same URL. Do not write that Curebound granted that award. Not a joint Ommid–Zanetti document.

circumstantial

Ommid Asbaghi → Pradeep Khosla

Curebound Concert for Cures committee list

Same committee page. Carolin Botzenhardt is also listed. Not a finding they collaborated on a hip.

documented

Hooman, 16 Feb 2025 email → Babak Hoghooghi

To: line; quoted denial of knowing Ommid and Sherry

He sent the accusation. The denial and backtrack are his sentences. No Babak reply is on that still.

circumstantial

Sherry Bahrambeygui → Laurie Black

same UC San Diego Foundation trustee list

Both bios are live on foundation.ucsd.edu. Same board. Not a finding they acted together, and not a finding about the hips.

documented

Laurie Black → Moores Cancer Center

2012 Extraordinary Caregiver of the Year

Public résumé and a 4 November 2012 reception notice. Caregiving is not a research appointment.

alleged

Laurie Black → Park Laurel

his account that she lived in the building

No public occupancy paper for a numbered unit is on this file. A 2019 brunch lists Home of Laurie Black & Stephen Skinner as a Balboa Park home, not a Park Laurel unit. Device claims stay alleged.

documented

Ommid Asbaghi → Sherry Bahrambeygui

Fall 2018 La Jolla Country Day School magazine donor lists

Same report on giving. Different giving societies. ’82 on Sherry’s row is a Country Day alumni year. Not a finding they funded a study on him.

documented

Ommid Asbaghi → Iranian-American Scholarship Fund

donor-thanks lists, 2018–19, 2020–21, 2021–22

The 2018–19 list also names Hooman Asbaghi. Donor thanks for those years, not a continuous 2010–2021 span, not a hip grant.

context

San Diego NCI Cancer Centers Council (C3) → Scripps Research

2013 Union-Tribune / Moores collaborating-sites copy

C3 members are Moores, Salk, and Sanford-Burnham. Scripps Research is named as a neighboring collaborating institute, not a C3 member.